An economic recipe to bankrupt Scotland | Letter | Politics

I am in broad agreement with Larry Elliott’s analysis of the four macroeconomic regime options that an independent Scotland would face (Nicola Sturgeon should not limit Scotland’s economic options, 30 August). I would, though, question his claim that sterlingisation is a “feasible” option, particularly with Scotland’s fiscal deficit heading north of 25% of GDP due to the pandemic.

Scotland persistently runs a deficit on the current account of its balance of payments of around 10% of GDP (£16bn). Currently this deficit is settled by the UK. With independence, Scotland would be responsible for financing its twin fiscal and current account deficits.

Sterlingisation is a form of fixed exchange rate and therefore does not provide a balance-of-payments adjustment mechanism, and since an independent Scotland would also no longer have fiscal transfers from the rest of the UK, it would need large-scale borrowing to compensate.

However, financial markets would not regard a fixed exchange rate system combined with large twin deficits as credible, and this would produce a classic currency crisis in which sterlingisation would have to be abandoned and replaced with a new separate currency at a sharply devalued rate.

The combination of no external adjustment mechanism and large-scale borrowing in a foreign currency, along with a unitary probability of devaluation, is simply a recipe for national bankruptcy.
Prof Ronald MacDonald
Adam Smith Business School, University of Glasgow

Join the conversation – email [email protected]

Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

Next Post

Live Music Market Analysis Highlights the Impact of COVID-19 (2020-2024) | Increased Popularity of Live Events to Boost the Market Growth

Sun Sep 6 , 2020
Technavio has been monitoring the live music market and it is poised to grow by USD 10.66 billion during 2020-2024, at a CAGR of over 9% during the forecast period. The report offers an up-to-date analysis regarding the current market scenario, latest trends and drivers, and the overall market environment. […]
Live Music Market Analysis Highlights the Impact of COVID-19 (2020-2024) | Increased Popularity of Live Events to Boost the Market Growth